The Weekly Planner – 4/3 – 4/9

For the past five-plus years, I’ve contributed The Week Ahead and Impact Report at Rotoworld. Those articles included a look at two-start pitchers, streamers, waiver pickups, and injuries. Many readers planned their week and FAAB deadlines around those articles, so my plan is to contribute something similar weekly throughout the 2023 season in this space.

My current intention is to post on Saturday, but with some more freeform notes rather than a set format. I’ll post my player and team observations from the past week, as well as some matchups to consider for the upcoming week, in addition to my look at the scheduled two-start pitchers and streamers.

If there’s something else you’d like to see, please let me know in the comments section.

 

Two Start Pitchers

American League

Strong Plays

Drew Rasmussen: @WAS, OAK

George Kirby: LAA, @CLE

Hunter Brown: DET, @MIN

Reid Detmers: @SEA, TOR

Jon Gray: BAL, @CHC

 

Decent Plays

Brady Singer: TOR, @SF

Nestor Cortes: PHI, @BAL

Kyle Bradish: @TEX, NYY

Nick Pivetta: PIT, @DET

Tyler Mahle: @MIA, HOU

Jose Berrios: @KC, @LAA

Yusei Kikuchi: @KC, @LAA

Michael Kopech: SF, @PIT

Matthew Boyd: @HOU, BOS

 

At Your Own Risk

Zach Plesac: @OAK, SEA

James Kaprielian: CLE, @TB

Kris Bubic: TOR, @SF

 

National League

Strong Plays

Carlos Carrasco: @MIL, MIA

Sean Manaea: @CHW, KC

 

Decent Plays

Steven Matz: ATL, @MIL

Freddy Peralta: NYM, STL

Charlie Morton: @STL, SD

Michael Grove: COL, @ARI

Taijuan Walker: @NYY, CIN

Drew Smyly: @CIN, TEX

Roansy Contreras: @BOS, CHW

 

At Your Own Risk

Ryne Nelson: @SD, LAD

Johnny Cueto: MIN, @NYM

Dylan Dodd: @STL, SD

Trevor Williams: TB, @COL

Ryan Feltner: @LAD, WAS

Connor Overton: CHC, @PHI

Chad Kuhl: TB, @COL

 

Streamers

These are pitchers I’m considering as single-start streamers this week in a 12-15 team mixed league that are available in at least 50% of leagues.

American League

Tyler Wells: @ TEX (4/4)

JP Sears: CLE (4/4)

Josh Fleming: @ WAS (4/4)

Hunter Gaddis: @ OAK (4/5)

Jhony Brito: @ BAL (4/8)

 

National League

Tylor Megill: MIA (4/6)

Bailey Falter: CIN (4/8)

 

Player Notes

  • I’m anxious to see the reported velocity risers, particularly those who pitched in the Cactus League, where data wasn’t as readily available. Several of those are two-start pitchers next week, including Reid Detmers and Sean Manaea. We also saw strong velocity trends in Spring Training from Nick Pivetta, Kyle Bradish, and Ryan Feltner, so that trio is worth watching as they make their first starts of the season.
  • Just because Michael Grove is gaining a rotation spot as a result of an injury, we shouldn’t assume he will lose it when Ryan Pepiot is ready to return. Grove is a solid prospect in his own right who has consistently posted a K/9 above 10.0 in the minors, and his 17/3 K/BB in 16.2 innings during Spring Training is indicative of a pitcher who could be taking the next step with his control. He has a very easy two-start week, and is worthy of an extra few bucks of FAAB for the chance those outings go well enough to keep his spot.
  • Kris Bubic has lost his luster as a prospect, but he’s one of the pitchers who could really benefit from KC’s new coaching staff. The lefty’s ERA ballooned above 5.00 last season, but he had a more respectable 4.40 ERA over his first two seasons after posting a pristine 2.23 ERA in 26 starts between Low-A and High-A in 2019. The Royals did him no favors by rushing him to the majors, and the control has been the big issues. The Royals have taken the more modern approach to throwing strikes in their new regime, encouraging pitchers to throw in the middle of the plate and let their movement work for them. This is a legitimate 12-team mixed league pitcher if Bubic’s control takes hold.
  • If you can find me a Jose Berrios fan who isn’t nervous heading into the season, I’ll call you a liar. The velocity and effectiveness was up and down again this spring in spite of some promising talk about his mechanical adjustments during the offseason. It should be noted that Berrios really didn’t lose much velocity last season, but his mechanics were all over the place and he certainly lost confidence. He didn’t do anything in Spring Training to regain that confidence, though the Jays are doing us a favor by moving to Monday to make his first start at Kansas City, compared to the alternative of facing St. Louis in the team’s first series.
  • There’s been some worry that Tylor Megill’s velocity was down during Spring Training after suffering arm injuries last season. Though, I think it’s important to note that Megill’s velocity was well up early last season, yet he developed into a sleeper prior to 2022 after posting 99/27 K/BB in 89.2 innings during his rookie campaign. That’s to say I believe Megill is capable of being very effective at a lower velocity. More concerning was his lack of control during Spring Training, with 13 walks in 17 innings.
  • How should we treat Colorado’s closer situation? It’s impossible to say when Daniel Bard might return from anxiety, though the fact that he’s still with the team and throwing is a good sign. There are two facts to consider: 1) Bud Black has demonstrated loyalty as a manger, particularly to veterans. He stuck with Bard for far too long as the closer in 2021, even after he struggled. 2) Pierce Johnson is a native of Colorado, and showed very capable in his first save chance on Friday on the road. Johnson’s injury history is long, but he looks healthy at the moment. I’d expect Bard to work his way back into the job whenever he returns, but you might be able to net a handful of saves from Johnson in the meantime.
  • German Marquez pitched better on Opening Day vs. San Diego than I saw in all of 2022. Before poo-pooing a Colorado starting pitcher, consider that Marquez was a playable option in 12-team mixed leagues from 2017-2021 with 175-plus strikeouts in three seasons and a sub-1.30 WHIP in four seasons. We saw some velocity decline in 2021 and 2022, but Marquez averaged 96.1 mph on Opening Day, which is the best velocity of his career. We often talk about using Rockies hitters at Coors Field, but Marquez has also proven to be a serviceable road situational option with a career 3.75 ERA, 1.17 WHIP, and 8.3 K/9. I’m comfortable using him on the road, even at Dodger Stadium next week.
  • Aledmys Diaz was an overlooked hitting option during draft season. He should open some eyes now that he’s starting for Oakland at shortstop vs. right-handed pitching and batting third in the order. The run-scoring opportunities are still limited in that lineup, but per 162 games Diaz is a .267-21-75 hitter in his career. You could do worse for a middle infielder.
  • Ji Hwan Bae got the surprising start at second base for Pittsburgh on Opening Day and made the most of it with two hits and two steals. I felt that Bae was an underrated fantasy prospect, with high batting average and elite speed. His added versatility with the new ability to play the outfield gives him even more intrigue. If the production continues, it’s also inevitable that we’ll see Bae near the top of the order as a high batting average and OBP player.
  • There’s a lot of attention paid to Joey Wiemer’s promotion by Milwaukee not only for the fact that he was promoted but also for the fact that Sal Frelick was not promoted. The promotion made sense from a team construction standpoint because Wiemer is right-handed, an area of weakness for the Brewers roster. However, Wiemer was outplayed in Spring Training by Frelick, and my long-term outlook for Frelick is much higher. That’s not to say Wiemer can’t help fantasy teams as a 20/20 man in back-to-back seasons, but his margin for error is small with Frelick behind him plus the eventual return of Tyrone Taylor. As for Frelick, I actually his path to the majors in center field, where young Garrett Mitchell currently resides. Mitchell had a good spring and solid MLB debut last season, but his contact skills aren’t up to Frelick’s standard.

Fantasy Baseball Starting Pitcher Rankings 2023

Updated 01/22/23

Rankings based on 15-team mixed, standard roto-scoring leagues.

Rating: 1-5, 5 is likely improvement, 1 is likely decline

Status: Sleeper (S), Deep Sleeper (DS), Bust (B)

RankPlayerLGTeamPosCommentsRatingStatus
1Corbin BurnesNMILSPK/9 regression of last two months but still elite, cutter is best pitch in baseball.3
2Gerrit ColeANYYSPElite in consecutive years, still having HR issues. Very safe.3
3Aaron NolaNPHISPPerfect control, pitched better than ERA. Not GB pitcher anymore but probably safest on the board.4
4Max ScherzerNNYMSPVelo declined very slightly three consecutive years with K rate. Best control of career. Still has innings upside.3
5Jacob deGromATEXSPK/BB identical to 2021 but had HR issues. Velo down slightly but not much.3
6Kevin GausmanATORSPMore sliders, ridiculous control. Due better luck with BABIP.4
7Spencer StriderNATLSPBetter k/BB as SP, elite velo. Missed time with oblique. ERA should have been even better. Innings cap likely.4
8Carlos RodonANYYSPMaintained velo. Elite minus durability.3
9Shane McClanahanATBRSPElite control. Wore down late, particularly September. Adds some risk.2
10Brandon WoodruffNMILSPSame as usual. Safe other than health.3
11Zac GallenNARISPAdded velo, all plus pitches. Ridiculous second half. Looks like ace but slightly overachieved.3
12Justin VerlanderNNYMSPVelo excellent despite K/9 decline. HR success a bit fluky.3
13Shohei OhtaniALAASPHuge velo increase and throwing more sliders. Reflected in dominant K/BB. Possibly better pitcher than hitter.3
14Sandy AlcantaraNMIASPOnly difference was vastly improved changeup. ERA metrics only slightly improved, and K rate dropped. Obvious regression.2
15Zack WheelerNPHISPVelo and GB rate down. Was back in the playoffs. Injuries are only concern.3
16Luis CastilloASEASPNo longer GB pitcher, FB was elite. Juiced ball would be more risky.3
17Shane BieberACLESPVelo worst of career by far. Saved by cutter. Doesn't have previous upside.3
18Yu DarvishNSDPSPIP/GS easily best of career, sub-2.0 BB/9 again. Velo has been up for three years. HR still concerning if live ball returns.3
19Max FriedNATLSPBig control improvement, improved changeup that he threw more. Very safe pitcher.4
20Tyler GlasnowATBRSPLooks all the way back. Durability still a concern.3
21Dylan CeaseACHWSPPeripherals worse than 2021, throwing more sliders. Elite pitch. Likely regression to mid-3 ERA.2
22Joe MusgroveNSDPSPElite control again, has reached ceiling.3
23Cristian JavierAHOUSPFixed control, especially in second half.3
24Framber ValdezAHOUSP67% GB, huge velo increase. Finger and hand injuries in 2021. Only risk is workload.3
25Chris SaleABOSSPFluke injuries. Velo was very good in two starts.4S
26Logan WebbNSFGSP57% GB, velo declined from 2021. Safe but limited upside if velo doesn't return.3
27George KirbyASEASPBieber clone though non-fastballs are mediocre. Threw 156 IP.3
28Robbie RayASEASPLost a bit of velo from 2022, reflected in performance. Has been durable recently.3
29Clayton KershawNLADSPChronic back problems. Adjusted breaking pitches with success.3
30Logan GilbertASEASPAdded velo but not strikeouts. At his ceiling unless offspeed pitches improve.3
31Julio UriasNLADSPVelo down, K rate down. Clear regression pending.2B
32Brady SingerAKCRSPSlider improved, showed elite control. Not much room for growth but safe buy.3
33Drew RasmussenATBRSPAdded dominant cutter. 6.30 K/BB in second half. No longer GB pitcher and limited ceiling, but super safe and surging.4
34Jordan MontgomeryNSTLSPAdded control again, added strikeouts with STL. Very safe buy.4
35Nick LodoloNCINSPGB rate mediocre, got on track after injury. 2.92 ERA in second half. Limited workload still huge concern.3
36Lance LynnACHWSPKnee surgery, velo down. Elite control, easily best of career. Incredible over last two months.5S
37Blake SnellNSDPSPBest velo of career, slider was great. Awesome control after the break. Still not durable.3
38Charlie MortonNATLSPHR% spikes with FB. Pitched better after April struggles.3
39Jeffrey SpringsATBRSPVelo down as SP, changeup was elite. Even better in second half. HR spike possible with FB rate.3
40Alek ManoahATORSPElite control, had some issues missing bats. Regression very likely if it doesn't improve.2
41Joe RyanAMINSPAdded velo, extreme FB bit him. Got back on track after mediocre June and July. Has ability for better control performance.3
42Triston McKenzieACLESPElite control, two great pitches. Got better in second half. Some injury risk.3
43Kyle WrightNATLSP56% GB, velo rebound, trashed slider. Heavily threw excellent curveball. Safe mid-3's ERA.3
44Garrett WhitlockABOSSPHad hip surgery. Definite SP. Great control and huge upside.4S
45Alex CobbNSFGSPHuge increase in velo, 59% GB. An ace but health is huge concern.4S
46Chris BassittATORSPLooking more durable and consistent control. More sliders and curveballs, K/9 down in 2nd half.3
47Reid DetmersALAASP3.04 ERA, 3/1 K/BB after demotion. Looks elite.4S
48Marcus StromanNCHCSPHad elbow issue, bounced back fine. Same as usual.3
49Nestor CortesANYYSPAdded velo, ERA metrics above 3.3
50Hunter GreeneNCINSPExtreme FB rate is concerning in CIN. Ridiculously good late in year after returning from shoulder.3
51Aaron AshbyNMILSP57% GB, mediocre control as SP. ERA metrics show clear sub-4.00 ERA, but control prevents going all-in.4S
52Patrick SandovalALAASPMore sliders, excellent pitch. Mediocre control but got better late. HR rate likely to regress.3
53Alex WoodNSFGSPAdded velo, mid-3's ERA metrics. Ended season with shoulder.4
54Lucas GiolitoACHWSPVelo well down, ERA metrics still showed upper 3's ERA.3
55Adbert AlzolayNCHCSPPitched out of the pen in September and was dominant. Missed most of season with shoulder. Excellent sleeper.4S
56Dustin MayNLADSPBack injury. Velo and GB rate looked good, but struggled with control. Was great in minors.4
57Luis SeverinoANYYSPVelo mostly returned, secondary stuff not as good as previous. Missed time with shoulder injury.3
58Jameson TaillonNCHCSPAdded cutter, elite control again. Would benefit outside of NYY. Injury history somewhat concerning.3
59Kyle BradishABALSPFixed control in minors. 3.28 ERA in 2nd half. FB was mediocre but good velo. 4 ERA likely.4
60Pablo LopezAMINSPFirst time he's stayed healthy. Not dominant anymore. ERA near 5 in second half.3
61Kenta MaedaAMINSP
62Tyler MahleAMINSPShoulder problems, tried to pitch through shoulder late. Velo down a bit, getting out of CiN should help.3
63Andrew HeaneyATEXSPChronic arm and HR problems. Best velo of career, more sliders.3
64Jon GrayATEXSPAdded velo, HR problems. ERA metrics slightly better than results.3
65Grayson RodriguezABALSP
66Jose SuarezALAASPAdded slider, was plus pitch. Got on a roll in second half with 1.5 BB/9 due to plus pitch.4S
67Sean ManaeaNSFGSPBecame extreme FB pitcher, changeup was terrible. Especially bad in second half.3
68Zach EflinATBRSPVelo still down but showing elite control, pitched well as RP late in year.3
69Steven MatzNSTLSPChronic injuries, finished year healthy. Elite K/BB and velo looked good.4S
70Hunter BrownAHOUSPElite GB, nearly perfect in relief. Control still concerning, but blue chip if SP.4S
71Jose BerriosATORSPVelo was fine, K rate way down and worse in 2nd half. Getting killed by LH.3
72Nathan EovaldiATEXSPVelo falling in consecutive years but still good. HRs and injuries are concerning.2
73Andrew PainterNPHISP
74Braxton GarrettNMIASPAdded velo, more sliders. Looks legit. Very limited innings for career.3
75Bailey OberAMINSPGroin injury, lost a touch of velo. Elite control, HR% unlikely to continue with high FB. Scott Baker clone. Innings likely limited.4S
76Freddy PeraltaNMILSPShoulder issues. Velo was down, K rate way down in second half. Very risky.3B
77Jesus LuzardoNMIASPAdded velo, changeup was dominant pitch. More elbow problems/injury concerns.3
78Merrill KellyNARISPAdded velo but overachieved.2
79Carlos CarrascoNNYMSPVelo well down from peak and worst since rookie season. ERA metrics are better, but significant injury risk.2
80Brayan BelloABOSSPElite GB rate, 2.59 ERA in September but WHIP was ugly. Elite K rates in minors.4S
81Ken WaldichukAOAKSPGreat milb track record, impressive K/9 in minors. Good K/BB and finished strong.4
82David PetersonNNYMSPAdded velo, 10.9 K/9 as SP. Control issues but has big upside if healthy.3
83Eric LauerNMILSPAdded velo in consecutive seasons. Overcame elbow issue late. Mediocre ERA metrics due to HR issues, but mostly corrected in second half.3
84Tony GonsolinNLADSPVelo is down, but all offspeed were plus plus. Durability still in question and not great K rates.2
85Spencer TurnbullADETSP
86Justin SteeleNCHCSP51% GB, excellent slider. Slider still shaky and had back issues.3
87Jose QuintanaNNYMSPNo clear difference other than HRs. Very risky buy.2B
88Ross StriplingNSFGSPMore changeups, elite control. HR rate was lucky, and last year was clear upside.3
89Ranger SuarezNPHISP55% GB, added more pitches. Control better in second half but wasn't great.3
90Sonny GrayAMINSPVelo continuing to fall, reflected in K rate.2
91Bailey FalterNPHISPElite control but HR problems. Can overcome if 2nd half control continues.4S
92Matt BrashASEASP52% GB, mostly sliders. Very good in 2nd half as RP but still had control issues.3
93Miles MikolasNSTLSPComplete bounceback. Pitched a bit over his head, and still bad injury history.2B
94Tanner HouckABOSSPGood GB, back injury late in year. K rate dropped. Certainly limited innings.3
95Tyler AndersonALAASPImprovement from adjusted changeup, K/BB nearly same as 2021. Huge benefit from dejuiced ball.2B
96Martin PerezATEXSPGB rate up to 51%, K/BB the same. More likely high-3's ERA.3
97Trevor RogersNMIASPVelo was fine, command not as good. Back and lat injuries. K/BB was much better in five second half starts.3
98Frankie MontasANYYSPVery good before trade. Shoulder issues and down K rate in NY. Risky with park.3
99Roansy ContrerasNPITSPCommand issues in MLB, has much more upside than what he showed. Likely low innings cap.3
100Cody MorrisACLESPDominant in minors, huge K rates. All offspeed pitches are plus.4S
101Lance McCullers Jr.AHOUSPVelo and GB rate were down after return. Reason to question health.2B
102Aaron CivaleACLESPThree IL stints, elite in eight starts during 2nd half. ERA metrics sub-4 ERA but risk due to injuries and HRs.4DS
103Adam WainwrightNSTLSPVelo down more, identified mechanical issues that killed K/9 but still down slightly.3
104Cole IrvinAOAKSPElite control, nearly a repeat. Benefiting from home ballpark.3
105Tarik SkubalADETSPMore sliders, got HR problems in check. Midseason return from flexor.3
106JT BrubakerNPITSPVery good K/BB, but no effective pitches. 4 ERA metrics but reason for skepticism.3
107Kyle MullerAOAKSPFixed control at AAA but not in MLB. Added velo, has interesting upside.3DS
108Jakob JunisNSFGSPNow throwing sinkers and changeups. Fixed HR issues? Struggled late in year, ERA metrics show sub-4 ERA.4
109Taijuan WalkerNPHISPMore cutters and splitters added to GB rate. Minimal upside with K rate and history of durability issues.3
110Noah SyndergaardNLADSPVelo and K rate crashed. Not GB pitcher anymore.2
111Kodai SengaANYMSP
112Kyle GibsonABALSPVelo and GB rate has tanked. Throwing more offspeed, though ERA metrics were league average.3
113Yusei KikuchiATORSPTrashed cutter, threw slider harder. Velo was fine but no control.3
114Edward CabreraNMIASPChangeup most used and best pitch, control shaky but improved in second half. .207 BABIP.3
115Clarke SchmidtANYYSPVelo mostly bounced back, new slider that was excellent pitch. Dominant at AAA, better control in second half. Big upside.4S
116Eduardo RodriguezADETSPVelo down overall, was all over the place. Not a great risk until seeing how he does in ST.2
117Matthew BoydADETSPReturned from flexor tendon, velo was fine. Brutal control in small sample size.3DS
118Corey KluberABOSSPElite control. Velo way down, throwing cutters now.3
119Michael WachaAFASPLost some velo, new cutter looks good. Still has HR problems and K/9 is bad.2
120Anthony DeSclafaniNSFGSPVelo was well down, ankle surgery. Still showed elite control.3
121MacKenzie GoreNWSNSPElite in first two months until elbow gave out. Healthy at end of season.3S
122Trevor BauerNFASP
123JP SearsAOAKSPInconsistent, hasn't missed bats. Slider and changeup both plus pitches, and showed very good milb control.3
124Drew SmylyNCHCSPVelo up slightly, more curveballs and cutters. Great in second half, still risky due to injuries.3
125Nick MartinezNSDPSPWants back in the rotation, mediocre command as SP. 3
126Jose UrquidyAHOUSPVelo rebound, still major HR issues.3
127Brandon PfaadtNARISP
128DL HallABALSPPitched well in relief, likely long term role.3
129John MeansABALSPHad TJS in April, BAL could correct HR issues. Elite control.4
130Tylor MegillNNYMSPVelo increase, was an ace early before arm problems. Long injury history.3
131Yonny ChirinosATBRSPVelo looked good after elbow. Cheap innings.3DS
132Luis OrtizNPITSPSome struggles at AA. Elite velo and solid K/BB. Probably gets more time at AAA.3
133Mitch KellerNPITSPSolid velo increase and added sinker. Improvements in control and GB rate.3
134Dane DunningATEXSP53% GB but velo down again. Hip and ankle injuries. Some upside but needs velo jump.3
135Nick PivettaABOSSPVelo and K rate down. HR problems continue.3
136Jack FlahertyNSTLSPChronic shoulder problems, poor command.3
137Gavin StoneNLADSP
138Joey LucchesiNNYMSP
139Taylor HearnATEXSPRP to end year and was much better.3
140Josh WinderAMINSPExtreme FB, had shoulder issues. Scott Baker potential, very good breaking pitches.3DS
141Paul BlackburnAOAKSPVelo up slightly, GB only 47%. Effective curveball. Finger injury.2
142Andre PallanteNSTLSP64% GB. Good slider but doesn't miss bats. Solid end game add.3DS
143Matt ManningADETSPForearm issue but was healthy by end of year. Command has improved but trouble missing bats.3
144Kyle HarrisonNSFGSP
145Danny DuffyNFASP
146Hayden WesneskiNCHCSPShowed solid control, three plus pitches. Middle of the rotation SP.3
147Cal QuantrillACLESPLucky in consecutive years, ERA should be over 4.2B
148Drey JamesonNARISPGood in debut, had strong K/BB but lousy performance in minors. Good GB rate but risky.3
149Johan OviedoNPITSPBig velo increase, a lot of sliders. Control is a problem, but becoming more interesting.3DS
150Dean KremerABALSPNew cutter and more changeups. Cutter graded well but not missing bats.2
151Zach PlesacACLESPVelo down, still having HR issues. No upside.3
152Chase SilsethALAASPRushed to MLB. Plus velo and milb K rates. HR problems.3
153Jake OdorizziATEXSPHR issues with Braves. More cutters. Still a league average pitcher but durability issues three straight years.3
154Kutter CrawfordABOSSPAdded velo, major HR issues. K/BB shows potential.3
155Bryce ElderNATLSPDoesn't miss a lot of bats, but GB near 50%. Outstanding after initial struggles.3DS
156Domingo GermanANYYSPLost velo after shoulder, FIP was much higher.2
157Austin VothABALSPMore cutters and curveballs, bigger park really helped. Limited upside but looks like legit 4 ERA pitcher.3
158Michael KopechACHWSPVelo and K rate down. Claimed knee problems since June.3
159Louie VarlandAMINSPStrong milb track record, K/BB looked good but HR a concern.3
160Tyler WellsABALSPNot missing bats with velo issues as SP. HR issues, comparable to Urquidy.3
161Connor SeaboldABOSSPGood milb track record. Nice control potential, but FB rate is concerning.3
162Rich HillNPITSPMore offspeed, curveball starting to deteriorate.2
163Tanner BibeeACLESP
164Cole RagansATEXSPCommand started to show late, solid milb track record but more of a middle of the rotation pitcher.3
165Daniel LynchAKCRSPNo plus pitches. Continued control and HR issues. Control improved in second half.3
166Thad WardNWSNSP
167Mike SorokaNATLSP
168Josiah GrayNWSNSPHorrendous HR issues, control still a big problem. Showed much better control in minors.3
169Graham AshcraftNCINSPStruggled with control at AAA, but has otherwise been good. 55% GB, not right after return from bicep in September. Needs another pitch.3
170Garrett HillADETSPDidn't miss bats, but milb track record is excellent.4
171Ryan PepiotNLADSPPlus arm, really misses bats. Control and HR issues.3
172Ryne NelsonNARISPExtreme FB is concerning but has plus stuff. Elbow and shoulder injuries. Mediocre at AAA but good below that level.3
173Mitch WhiteATORSPMess in Toront, though ERA metrics were around 4 ERA.4
174Mike ClevingerACHWSPVelo down to 2018 level, slider was bad. Decline over last two months.2
175Cade CavalliNWSNSPShoulder injury, had control issues at AAA but generally solid.3
176Taj BradleyATBRSP
177James KaprielianAOAKSPBizarre trends. Added velo, K rate tanked. Slight improvement in second half. Injury history still a red flag.2
178Freddy TarnokAOAKSPBig arm. Control issues, decent at missing bats.3
179Angel ZerpaAKCRSPPlus velo and GB rate. K/BB was solid. Season ending with elbow injury.3DS
180Zack GreinkeAFASPChangeup has become crap, no strikeouts.3
181Keegan ThompsonNCHCSPMore HR and control issues, finished season in pen.3
182Simeon Woods RichardsonAMINSPNice debut, control back on track. Doesn't have much velo.3
183Chris FlexenASEASPVelo down, K rate was terrible.2
184Kolby AllardNATLSPMediocre year at AAA but missed bats. Not enough velo.3
185Shintaro FujinamiAOAKSP
186Griffin CanningALAASP
187Joe RossNFASP
188Bobby MillerNLADSP
189Jordan LylesAKCRSPVelo down significantly. Only difference was HR improvement with home park.2
190Elieser HernandezNNYMSPStill good K/BB but can't keep ball in park.3
191Kris BubicAKCRSPRidiculous .352 BABIP but made no progress, minor league history still shows a lot of upside.3DS
192Luis PatinoATBRSPVelo was down but good at AAA. Still a lot of time, but needs to fix control.3
193German MarquezNCOLSPVelo bounced back but GB crashed. Strikeout issues are red flag.2
194Josh FlemingATBRSPElite GB rate and control potential.3DS
195Drew RucinskiAOAKSP
196Vince VelasquezNPITSP
197Wade MileyNMILSPVelo consistently falling but decent GB rate. Chronic shoulder.3
198Ian AndersonNATLSPVelo down slightly, control was terrible. Doesn't look close to rebound.3
199James PaxtonABOSSP
200Paolo EspinoNWSNSPBrutal in 2nd half, 6 ERA as SP.2
201Jose ButtoNNYMSPSolid year, very good milb track record but has HR problems.3
202Beau BrieskeADETSPGreat control and changeup, missed more bats in the minors. HR issues are a big problem. Healthy from forearm at end of season. Scott Baker clone?3
203Joey WentzADETSPControl remains a concern, but showed improvement at AAA.3
204Dylan BundyAFASPAveraged less than 5 IP, velo way down. 5th SP at best.3
205Michael LorenzenADETSPMore injuries, more offspeed. Command is ugly.3
206Stephen StrasburgNWSNSPThoracic outlet and nerve issue. Just a 50th rounder.3
207Luis GilANYYSPHad TJS, can miss bats.3
208Marco GonzalesASEASPAll offspeed, terrible K rates.2B
209Adrian SampsonNCHCSPGood control but not missing bats. Possibly sticks as fifth SP.3
210Johnny CuetoNMIASPK rate tanked, more sinkers but success not supported by metrics.2B
211Sean HjelleNSFGSPExtreme GB, missed more bats in MLB and milb. Definite 5th starter ability.3DS
212Robert GasserNMILSP
213Eury PerezNMIASP
214Adrian MartínezAOAKSP
215Reiver SanmartinNCINSPDecent GB rate, terrible velo. Showed much better control before 2022.3
216Hunter GaddisACLESPExtreme FB pitcher with HR problems. Great milb K rates. Some upside.3
217Hunter GaddisACLESPExtreme FB pitcher with HR problems. Great milb K rates. Some upside.3
218Wilmer FloresADETSP
219Daniel CastanoNMIASPNew cutter, had labrum tear.3
220Ryan YarbroughAKCRSPVelo well down over last two years. Control much worse last year. Oblique issues.2
221Michael PinedaAFASPElite control, but velo and K rate has tanked in consecutive years.2
222Ethan SmallNMILSPFormer first round pick with nice K rate but awful control. Not great velo.3
223Michael PlassmeyerNPHISP
224Bruce ZimmermannABALSPLost velo, showed great control. Limited upside.3
225Nick NeidertNCHCSPExcellent rebound season, great control.3DS
226Mason MontgomeryATBRSP
227Bryce MillerASEASP
228Spencer HowardATEXSPMore sliders but pitch was terrible, struggling with control in minors. No sign of breakout.3
229Alex FaedoADETSPDidn't look good, but has very good milb track record with elite control.3DS
230Cole HenryNWSNSP
231Logan AllenACLESP
232Mike BaumannABALSPSwingman, struggled as SP late in the year. Showing good GB rate and velo.3
233Dakota HudsonNSTLSPVelo well down, 53% GB, brutal command and didn't miss bats.2
234Matthew LiberatoreNSTLSPHR problems and average stuff.3
235Zack KellyABOSSP
236Sixto SanchezNMIASP
237Mike MinorNFASPShoulder issues, velo was down and K rate tanked. Wrong part for his skillset.3
238Patrick CorbinNWSNSPGood velo, slider is completely gone. ERA metrics not that bad.3
239Madison BumgarnerNARISPVelo bounced back, slider has been terrible. Same issues as Corbin.3
240Mick AbelNPHISP
241Cole HamelsNFASP
242Brad KellerAKCRSPMissed bats in relief, GB rate is back. Could stick as RP.3
243Adrian HouserNMILSP59% GB, velo was fine. Poor control.3
244Davis MartinACHWSPNever had success but missed bats in minors.3
245Michael GroveNLADSPBreakout year, has always shown good K rates.3
246Zach DaviesNARISPVelo rebound, changeup was good. League average again.3
247Bryse WilsonNPITSPShowed some improvement late in the year. K rate still too ugly.3
248Jonathan HeasleyAKCRSPHasn't missed bats in MLB, good K rates in minors.3
249Austin GomberNCOLSPLosing velo every year, RP in second half.3
250Caleb KilianNCHCSPGood GB rate, control tanked. Needs to repeat AAA.3
251Kyle HendricksNCHCSPShoulder problems, curveball has been ineffective in consecutive years. HR issues.2
252Brandon WilliamsonNCINSP
253Janson JunkNMILSPExcellent control since 2021 and a good development team. Has some upside.3DS
254Josh WinckowskiABOSSP52% GB, didn't miss bats in MLB.3
255Brett AndersonNFASP
256Glenn OttoATEXSPFound control in September, but still not missing bats. Has momentum for rotation spot.3
257Konnor PilkingtonACLESPMediocre control, doesn't have a plus pitch. Likely regression.2
258Kyle FreelandNCOLSPVelo well down, not clear how he was better.2
259Jason AlexanderNMILSPExtreme GB pitcher who can't miss bats.3
260Chad KuhlNFASPVelo worst of career.2
261Zach ThompsonNPITSPNo plus pitches, poor command.2
262Tyler AlexanderADETSPK rate plunged. Changeup has been ineffective. Clear 5th SP.3
263Noah DavisNCOLSPCould get some starts.3
264Max CastilloAKCRSPControl issues, mediocre stuff.3
265Luis CessaNCINSPDecent as SP, fewer sliders. Pitching to contact. Minimal upside.3
266Connor OvertonNCINSP
267Tommy HenryNARISPMajor control issues, doesn't have great stuff.3
268Julio TeheranAFASP
269Antonio SenzatelaNCOLSPSame as usual, torn ACL in August.3
270Chris ArcherAFASPSlight velo rebound but still well down. Never threw more than 5 IP.3
271Adam OllerAOAKSPDecent milb track record, but never got outs in MLB.3
272Quinn PriesterNPITSP
273Tucker DavidsonALAASPHorrible control in MLB, still shows milb upside.3
274Jay GroomeNSDPSP
275Carlos HernandezAKCRSPStill elite velo, doesn't miss enough bats.3
276Cory AbbottNWSNSPHas shown decent K rates in minors. No control and HR issues.3
277Connor PhillipsNCINSP
278Javier AssadNCHCSPSudden K improvement at AAA, mediocre velo and command in MLB.2
279Spenser WatkinsABALSPNew cutter, still no upside.2
280Ryan WeathersNSDPSP
281Joan AdonNWSNSPGood velo, horrendous control at all levels.3
282Ryan FeltnerNCOLSPVelo increase, slider was good.3
283Peter LambertNCOLSP
284Justin DunnNCINSPVelo down, terrible command. More shoulder problems.3
285Jose UrenaNCOLSP50% GB, doesn't miss bats.3